I saw the changes for the first time at the weekend. I also wanted to see Ramin & Sierra one last time before they finished. I was one of those (unlike many theatre critics) who loved the show and didn't feel as if any changes really needed to be made and so went expectantly, having really enjoyed my first three trips and looking forward excitedly to my fourth.Dancer wrote:To me some are better as they improve the sense and flow of the show, whilst others were perhaps unecessary. At least all the big numbers are still there!
To be honest I actually left a little disappointed!! I felt the story flowed a little better, but didn't think the score flowed anywhere near as well and seemed a bit fractured. I'm glad all the projections were kept, but didn't like the fact that the show now started with no overture, but with the best song in the score - 'Til I Hear You Sing'. The slightly revised ending was okay, but basically the whole show lacked the emotional intensity it did for me the first three times and I left feeling 'nothing' whatsover, except a tad short changed.
Ramin & Sierra do have AWESOME voices and I'm glad I had the opportunity of hearing them again. On the night we had Jack Costello (ex Nipper in 'Oliver') for Act 1 and then Thomas Celik for Act 2. I knew Jack was in the show and he has a great voice and acting ability, but unfortunately he does not look anywhere near 10 years of age. Thomas looked a bit older and again did well, but still I feel they have recruited these new 'Gustaves' a bit too young.
I don't think I need to go and see this show again.
Shame, I wish the critics hadn't been so harsh and that ALW was strong enough to leave 'good enough' alone!